sab39 ... Book 7 prediction!

7/18/2005

Okay, I'm blogging this one more with a view to pointing back to it after book 7 is finally released and saying "look, I had it 3 days after Prince was released!"

Click through for the prediction. MAJOR SPOILERS for HBP inside.

We know that Voldemort was looking for items belonging to Ravenclaw and Gryffindor to complete his Horcrux collection.

We know that Dumbledore believes that "the only known relic" of Gryffindor's - presumably the sword - is safely in his office. Note that he uses the singular here.

We know that Voldemort showed up at Hogwarts - in Dumbledore's office no less - to request a job that he knew Dumbledore was not going to give him. Dumbledore called him on this, but he gave no true reason. We also know that his hand flicked to his wand in Dumbledore's office.

But - and here's the crucial part - we know that Dumbledore is wrong that there's only one relic of Gryffindor's remaining in existence. Remember the Sorting Hat's song from Phoenix?

"Twas Gryffindor that saw the way,
He whipped me off his head:
The founders put some brains in me
So I could choose instead."

So here's the prediction:

While Dumbledore may have forgotten that the Hat is a Gryffindor relic, I'm sure Voldemort didn't. I'm not sure how exactly he managed to kill somebody (necessary to make a Horcrux) with his hand and wand in his pocket in Dumbledore's office, but I'm absolutely convinced that that's what he did.

The Sorting Hat is the Gryffindor horcrux that Harry's searching for!

predictions....

By tincho at 2005/07/25 01:11

aja, nice point...could Fawkes count as killing¿? even if it's a fenix...that way DD would never realize cause it would be re-born

Great

By Tyler (Email) at 2005/07/25 12:45

Great, how r you so good at figuring out wath will happen? E-mail me bout what you think - McConville_T@hotmail.com

RAB

By stellaluna (Email) at 2005/07/25 16:13

I think RAB is Regulus Black, Sirius's brother. He died 16 years ago trying to leave the death eaters.

RAB

By Josh N at 2005/08/01 00:49

I agree with the RAB comment. His name came up quite obviously several times in HBP and depending on his middle name the initials fit, plus as a Death Eater he could easily have figured out LV's "Secret". In OotP it doesn't say his middle name on the family tree. Any other ideas about RAB?

RAB

By JAY at 2005/08/02 09:41

I think everyone is right about RAB who knows maybe voldy killed him cus he did destroy the horcrux.

nothing

By saleem at 2005/08/02 17:38

i cant figure out why the summoning charm harry used at the cave aroused the inferni if there was no horcrux in the basin!

inferi

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/08/02 21:06

The inferi were probably set up to be triggered if anyone *attempted* to take the horcrux. Perhaps Voldemort considered every spell that anyone might attempt - Accio being one - and set the inferi to wake up whenever any of those were cast in the cave...

"fake" horcrux

By cassi (Email) at 2005/08/08 03:53

the locket is no fake - lord voldemort planted that note, so that if someone were to ever find it, they would think it wasn't real and just toss it. why else would JK have harry keep it??

Please don't be rude

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/08/09 15:06

I deleted comments by someone called Anna-Marie.

She correctly pointed out that there was a locket at 12 Grimmauld Place and RAB is Regulus Black. But being right is no excuse for being rude and calling the previous poster "stupid" is not something I'm going to tolerate on my site. Sorry.

Wrong song

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/08/09 23:13

Actually the hat's song reference quoted above was from _Goblet_, not _Phoenix_. Sorry.

Off Subject

By Guy at 2005/08/09 23:31

I think that harry will return to hogwarts and talk to Dumbledore through the picture of him in dumbledores old ofice. I also think that snape will bring news back to harry of a horcruxe that he has destroyed on his absence. I also think that harry will destroy a few more horcruxes while at hogwarts. He will then bring with him Ron, Hermione, Neville, Mcgonagal, Hagrid, Gwarp (the giant), and the order. I think that there will be a huge showdown and Mcgonagal will die but snape will then kill a few death eaters (yes Snape) and harry will destroy voldemort and his scar wil dissapear to only allow voldemort to gain the last horcruxe and then be destroyed by Neville. Neville will also die. Hagrid wil die while saving harry by a spell.

Those are alot of random predictions but i believe i am right in alot of them.

House Elves

By Mr. Prongs (Email) at 2005/08/11 03:02

I think that the house-elves are going to join the good side of the war. Did you see Dobby blow away Lucius? They haev some crazy powers.

House Elves

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/08/11 13:56

I can picture it now - house elf blows death eater off his feet and then bangs its head hard against a nearby table - "Bad elf! Bad elf!"

rumors surrounding harry's death

By holyeternalx (Email) at 2005/08/12 03:01

many have made predictions that Harry himself will die killing Voldemort. While I personally think this sounds very reasonable, and a very poetic ending. I have serious doubts as to it actually happening. First based on the fact that no matter how dark or how adult these books get, they are still fanciful fantasy literature, and it wouldnt fit the story to kill the hero at the end. Second is that to kill a character that an author has made us love for 7 books and many years no matter how much dramatic punch it might give, I dont think Rowling would want to anger her readers to such a degree. I do however believe that a person is the last horcrux, whoever it may be will obviously die.

One backup theory many people have for the death of Harry is rational logic. What use is there for Harry after Voldemort is dead. Harry has served his literary role and his personal role by offing the most evil wizard that ever lived. However looking at any war in history would dictate rational logic flow to the opposite side of the argument. After Hitler died WWII didnt end that moment, there was fighting for some time after. The same would be true if Voldemort died. Someone else might try to take his place seeing that Voldemort's goals are nearly realized, and most certainly Death Eaters will remain that need to be brought to justice. Harry's role would be obvious, take a position as an Auror and clean up the mess that Voldemort left behind.

Various theories

By Phioenixofshadows (Email) at 2005/08/17 20:10

If the last horcrux is a person, could it possibly be snape or wormtail? It would explain why LV didn't kill him, though he seems to hate him. Also, the RAB theory is, in my opinion, correct if it means Remus A. Black. He may still be alive. One last theory; It may be that the veiol that Sirius Black fell through is a portal, a "safety zone" in which you hang between life and death. That not only explains the voices but also allows Sirius to come back, using the mirror that he gave Harry. He may also bring other spirits with him.

Why did Snape kill Dumbeldore?

By Martin (Email) at 2005/08/19 09:00

Just thought I would chime in with my theories on what has been going on.

Basically Snape is a good guy who is pretending to be bad. Why hasn’t Voldermote figured him out yet when he is such a good mind reader (as the books keep telling us)? Well if you read carefully you will hear Lupin stating that Snape was the best oclumentist he had ever know, so Snape could keep this hidden from Voldermort where no one else could.

Next did you notice how all the death eaters were saying that the Dark Lord had ordered that Malfoy must kill Dumbledore and no one else, but Snape totally ignored this and killed Dumbledore straight away, why did he risk Voldermort’s fury by disobeying orders? He had to do it to stop Malfoy killing Dumbledore because if Malfoy had killed him then he would be really dead NOT as he is now, simply somewhere waiting to return. I think the argument heard between Snape and Dumbledore was Snape not wanting to kill him and when he was questioning Malfoy he was simply trying to find out how Malfoy was going to do it so that he could stop him and not have to do it himself.

I think the comment about the sorting hat being a horcrux may be correct BUT is it Voldermort’s or could it be Dumbledore’s, saying that to create a horcrux means that you must kill and who has Dumbledore killed?

Harry's Death

By MrFeZ at 2005/08/20 21:03

This sounds allot like the story of Jesus. Harry kills all sin and then dies. Just thought I'd chime in. Sounds alot like neo in the Matrix, The One anyone.

Dumbledore

By Ben Pavlick (Email) at 2005/08/26 23:33

Dumbledore is famous for defeating a dark wizard called Grindelwald according to the chocolate frog. Dumbledore is not without faults. Killing Grindelwald may have ripped his soul.

Dumbledore's past, present and future, Snape and RAB

By Phil (Email) at 2005/09/02 19:02

Snape is unfathomable, but I believe he is truly working for the Order. Hermione said "evil is a strong word" (p595 UK hbp) and I believe she is right. Snape is neither nice or evil. He is in the Order for a reason, and his loathing of Harry makes him ideal to pass him off as Voldemort's 'favourite' - Narcissa's words and 'trusted advisor'. If Snape had not killed Dumbledore, Snape would have died because of the unbreakable vow, and Snape's death would not be good for the Order. Now Snape seems to be truly alone because Dumbledore is unable to vouch for Snape, so is he going to be reporting to anyone? Besides, Dumbledore must have known he was going to die anyway - Trelawney's ever growing accurate predictions, it seems: "two of spades: conflict" "seven of spades: an ill omen. Ten of spades: violence. Knave of spades: a dark young man possibly troubled, one who dislikes the questioner-" (pages 185 - the house of gaunt/507 - seer overheard UK HPB) Talking about Malfoy and Dumbledore's conversation on the Lightning Struck Tower.
And Dumbledore gave Snape the post of DADA teacher for a reason. Snape only allows students with an O Owl level but Slughorn takes students with an E. If Harry didnt do potions (to be an auror by McGonagall's encouragement), he would not have known about the Half Blood Prince. Did Snape anticipate this? I think Snape's first mention of Half Blood Prince was in the duel between Snape and Harry, and he must have known about this when Harry used the Sectumsempra spell - he is a good occlumens and a good legilimens, possibly better than Voldemort - (possibly hinted on page 31 UK) In Book 5, Snape talks about 'handing weapons', clear your mind of emotions. In book 6, he calls out 'mouth shut and your mind closed'. Snape is trying to help Harry to master Occlumency.

RAB? Regulus Black? or two people - R and B. Would they stand for first names or last names? Two many possibilities I think. Although an idea - the Horcrux could be in the Inferi's hand when Harry said Accio horcrux and that was Regulus Black. Regulus would have needed to make more than one trip to the cave, to drink the potion/ to replace the real with a fake/ and replace with a new potion. He needed a quill too and some parchment. Careful planning was needed, or maybe he had all the stuff with him already. JKR said Regulus Black was a 'fine guess' but i am not entirely sure.

And Dumbledore himself? His background, for example. How did he learn Mermish? like Harry asked. His history is important, and I dont think Dumbledore had his soul ripped. Defeat of Grindelwald doesnt necessary mean Horcrux creation and i am sure that Dumbledore prefers death than have his soul ripped. Also, I think Dumbledore is dead and cannot return to the living - his portrait in his old office suggests he is dead. What about his phoenix though?

RAB

By Nikki (Email) at 2005/09/04 10:46

I think RAB is Regulus Black beacuse in the 5th book when Harry was claening out Sirius' cabinets, they found a locket--that no one could open...so...Regulus put a fake locket in the cave as it's place.

Harry's death

By Nikki (Email) at 2005/09/04 10:49

I think Harry won't die in the end of bnook 7. JK Rowmling will disapoint MANY readers...she will make less money by destroying Hagrid, Ron, Hermione, and Harry. Readers would be so disapointed

Harry not a Horcrux

By Jake at 2005/09/05 22:42

You guys are missing something when you say that Harry is a horcrux. Why would Voldemort make something that he wants to destroy a horcrux? This would mean that he would have to destroy his own horcrux and that would defeat the purpose of making him a horcrux. He also would not make Snape or Wormtail a horcrux because that would make him attached to people. Dumbledore said himself that Voldemort can't be attached to anyone and by making them a horcrux that means he can't destroy them and then that would become a weakness and he is smarter than that. Dumbledore also said that living things usually are not made into horcruxes.

Fortescue's disappearance

By Kin at 2005/09/15 11:17

Could Fortescue's missing nature help find the other horcrux? Florean Fortescue could be a descendant of the other Fortescue, the past Headmaster of Hogwarts - one of the portraits...Ollivander too is missing. Ravenclaw is definitely in there somewhere.

Personally i dont think Nagini is a Horcrux nor is Harry, because both can die and both are mortal, and since DD said so and like Jake said.

Sirius Black may not be dead

By Drisc (Email) at 2005/09/20 09:42

Well I just wondered about the snippet of news that Mundungus was sent to Azkaban for impersonating an inferi. I think it possible that Sirius is not dead but is working with Mundugus collecting objects that may be horcruxes. M liked S a lot and would be unlikely to steal his stuff. Maybe S and M were caught in a burglary trying to get horcruxes and S was spotted but thought to be M pretending to be an inferi. What do you think?

Fortescue

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/09/22 14:41

Kin, good catch! We know two things about Florean Fortescue - he makes good ice-cream, and he knows a great deal about medieval witch-burnings. The ice-cream probably isn't significant but the witch-burnings suggest a long family history, and the connection to the past Head is very well spotted indeed!

Ollivander certainly seems like a born Ravenclaw, and I'm sure too his disappearance will be significant, but I'm not sure how yet. Perhaps Voldemort's got him making a new wand that's not vulnerable against Harry's due to the shared core...

On Sirius

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/09/22 14:44

Drisc, I posted this (more or less) on TLC back in July 2004. It sums up my opinion on the "Sirius might be alive" movement pretty well. With apologies to Monty Python:

'E's not pinin'! 'E's passed on! This wizard is no more! He has ceased to be! 'E's expired and gone to meet 'is maker! 'E's a stiff! Bereft of life, 'e rests in peace! If 'e 'adn't disappeared through the veil 'e'd be pushing up the daisies! 'Is metabolic processes are now 'istory! 'E's off the twig! 'E's kicked the bucket, 'e's shuffled off 'is mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleedin' choir invisibile!! THIS IS AN EX-PADFOOT!!

theories on why Snape hates Harry

By Eli (Email) at 2005/09/24 14:31

One thing that has always puzzled me is why Snape hates Harry so much. The explanation that he hated Harry's father just seemed to thin to sustain such visceal hatred. But it seems, Book 7, has provided a possible explanation. Suppose that Snape was in love with Lily. Presumably she was not in love with him (horrible thought), but she was popular and probably lots of blokes were in love with her. Slughorn makes some comment about obsessive love being a dangerous potion (or something like that). I could imagine Snape being obsessively in love (but squelching it, of course, since he'd probably get rejected big time and he's not a very secure person). Anyhow so he is the one that reports the prophecy to Voldemort. So he is the one that directly lead to Lily's death. Big time guilt and self-loathing on account of that. I don't think that remorse in itself is what made Dumbledore trust Snape (that's not strong enough) -- unless Snape did something to try to stop Voldemort (unbeknownst to V) and somehow assisted in Voldemort downfall. That would be enough, I think to convince Dumbledore, but that seems like a bit of a stretch in terms of plausible plots.

Ok, so Snape loved Lily, Snape led to Lily's death, Snape hates himself. I'd believe that. He acts like someone who hates himself. Who is the other person most directly responsible for Lily's death? Harry. Lily died to save Harry, and Voldemort has said that Lily did not need to die. This is something that would be enough to cause Snape to hate Harry -- sure it's illogical since Harry was a baby and Lily chose to die for him. But to Snape, Harry is the reason Lily is dead (that and Snape himself). This also leads to lots of internal conflict -- he hates Harry, on the otherhand Harry is Lily's son, so probably wouldn't actually hurt him, just hate him.

This theory depends on 2 somewhat sketchy items:
a) Snape loved, obsessively, Lily
b) Snape was at Godric Hollow and saw what happened. How else would he know that Lily died (unnecessarily) to save Harry's life? That bit of info doesn't come out publicaly in the wizard world until long after Book 1.

Ok, that's my theory. Must wait 2 years to see if it is true...

P.S. There is a unsolved puzzle in this. That memory Harry saw of Snape snogging (one presumes) in the garden. JKR put that in for a reason, but I highly doubt that it was Lily.

Snape and Harry

By Stuart Ballard at 2005/09/24 15:43

I think there are a LOT of possibilities that come from the "Snape was unrequitedly in love with Lily" theory.

One other reason that might lead to Snape hating Harry: Harry is the physical symbol of the fact that Lily gave herself to someone else - and not just anyone, but Snape's arch-rival. The physical resemblance between Harry and James must be a constant reminder of that to him, especially since he has, as we're so often reminded, Lily's eyes. Imagine how Harry would feel if Ginny ended up marrying and having a son with Draco, and the son looked (and acted) just like Draco but with the striking Weasley red hair!

I don't think he needs to know that Lily died unnecessarily to save Harry to lead to the hatred we see, but even if he does, it's entirely possible that Dumbledore told him that. Dumbledore knew - don't know how, but he knew.

Can you tell me where exactly Harry saw Snape snogging in a garden? I don't remember that, and you're right that it sounds significant.

I'm still deeply convinced that Snape is "that awful boy" that Petunia overheard telling Lily about dementors. Snape knew an awful lot about the dark arts...

Lily and Harry

By Kin at 2005/10/04 15:22

I was thinking about Lily and Harry. When the spell backfired, did Lily INTENTIONALLY give Harry LV's powers? She had a choice to save herself, but as any mother, she saved her son by sacrificing her love. And Snape...could he have helped prevent Harry from getiting burnt or fully destroyed - like in HBP, Snape prevented DD's black hand from spreading...

Snape, Felix

By Danny at 2005/10/17 17:01

Ron survived cos of Snape. Without the HBP's book, Harry could not have picked out the Bezoar during the lesson and handed over to Slughorn, so to give Ron on his birthday.

Felix Felicis was because of Snape. Harry couldnt have got FF unless Slughorn became the Potions Master and Harry given the HBP book.

This is turning out to be a conspiracy, the whole lot of them is in on it!

But of course FF does what it should do, but IF ITS LUCKY - DD shouldnt have died, Snape and Draco would not have escaped. UNLESS, you count all these events as lucky - DD's death should happen, Draco and Snape should leave.

Ron, Hermy, Neville and Luna, i presume took the FF potion, and all survived, was that the FF porion meant to do or was the actual outcome of DD's death intended?

Killing DD doesnt necessarily make Snape evil, but the act is cruel. BUT in order for Voldemort to die, Snape MUST BE a double agent - if u cant beat them, join them.

Ruling out all 'Snap may still be on the good side' theories

By Heather (Email) at 2005/12/14 17:13

Okay, now we know that Snape has killed Dumbledore, was included in the murder of Lily and James, he has created multiple dangerous spells as the "Half Blood Prince", and he performed the Crutiatus (hope I spelled that right, hehe) curse on Harry! There is absolutely no reason for commiting any of these crimes EVEN if you have never commited a sin in your life. This is just a reminder for all of those HP fans that say that Snape may just be acting as though he is on the dark side and that he may still be good. Because guess what? HE'S A BAD, BAD, BAD BOY!!!!!

The last horcrux

By Theodora (Email) at 2005/12/19 06:59

You said "I do however believe that a person is the last horcrux, whoever it may be will obviously die."
What if the last horcrux is Harry? His scar could be the mark of it?
Although I suppose Voldemort's always trying to kill him, but what if it was an accident?

the scar

By maeve neary*(amsterdam) (Email) at 2005/12/19 11:09

actually as i just read a piece by guy "off suject"in which i dissagree with most of his pionts but when he said about harry killing voldemort and the scar dissapearing, i thought about the scar. and how it hurt when something was happning to voldemort-why would a scar hurt? harry got the scar when his parents ere killes, you need to kill someone to make a horcrux-> maybe harry potters scar is a horcrux. though i now wonder why voldemort would then want to kill harry potter if harry was carrying the horcrux with him, but hwo knows j.k rowling would ofcorse be able to find an explanation. i have found an really good site of predictions for book 7, i will post the link later. x maeve

last horcrux

By jess at 2005/12/23 05:48

OMG i've just realised! dumbledore knew he was going to die, because HE WAS A HORCRUXE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

last horcrux response

By liz at 2005/12/23 05:50

yeah! obviously! it makes everything so much sadder too... :( that makes voldy so much more evil, and dumbledore sacraficed himself!!! (even tho he did that anyway, by keeping harry under the cloak).

why did snape kill Dumbledore

By clever person with lots of ideas! lol! at 2005/12/23 06:05

Maybe snape didn't know the plan, like he said to narcisaa, and he was under Dumbledore's order to spy and to agree to whatever she asked of him, to gain his trust. i bet dumbledore told him to agree what Narcissa said, no matter what - because he knew that Voldemort would never want Snape to kill Harry - as he has to kil harry himself. i think that harry is the only person who Dumbledore would want to protect more than anything - especially more than himself.
maybe Snape realised from malfoy the plan, and had to kill him in the end, but he actually didn't want to deep down.
i know a lot of people are saying that Snape isn't really evil, deep down, but what made me think that he is, is the fact that just as Snape came onto the roof at this point, Dumbledore said his last words, he actually begged "Severus, please!" he did not want to die, and Snape did the cruellest thing he could have - murder the only person who really cared about him. and that's the thing isn't it? u can c from when harry red some of his thoughts and looked into snape's pensieve in book 5, that Snape has never known real love. i'm sorry, but as nice as james potter might have been or turned, there was no excusing how cruel he was to Snape. i think that's what it is, this incredible loathing on Snape's inside. i think he changed back to the bad side after the pensieve moment in book 5, or some time when he remebered his hate.

R.A.B

By Nayana (Email) at 2005/12/27 01:35

Snape is R.A.B

But R.A.B stands for??????

Death of Dumbledore, Snape Good and RAB

By Woodyplace (Email) at 2005/12/29 09:21

I think that RAB is Rabestan Le Strange. I think that he didn't know how evil Voldemort was. Now he does and is fighting back. I think that Snape did not kill Dumbledore. You have to mean for the Avada Kadavra to kill or it won't. Bellatrix said so in the Order of the Phoenix. Snape loved Dumbledore and Dumbledore trusted him. Plus, Dumbledore would not beg. He said that death was just another journey. I also think that Harry is not a horcrux. Only the scar is. The scar is inanimate. It give Harry the ability to speak Parseltongue and it hurts when voldermort is near. That's Voldermort's soul hurting.

Dumbledore's Killing

By Natalie at 2005/12/30 21:03

I have 2 theories about Dumbledore's death. First....I think it is CERTAIN that his death was carefuly planned between himself and snape. Dumbledore sacrificed himself so that voldermort would remain thinking that snape is on his side so in the end he can help harry ..meaning dumbledore really died OR ...snape, being so skilled in defence against the dark art could have figured out a loop hole and dumbledore is still alive.althought the first one seems more sensible. and i do think that i the end..harry dies some how...weather he is a horcrux or some how...BUT ..i think neville will die trying to kill voldermort because the prphect in book 5 revealed that it could be neville to kill him also.OR harry will ORDER neville to kill him in the middle of battle when he suddenly realizes that he himself is the last piece of voldermorte's soul. that will be sooooo SAD cuz he will leave ron and hermoine but it will be brilliant

death

By Jim at 2005/12/31 20:32

Dumbledore isnt dead, and he and Harry will figure out that the last horcrux is the sorting hat. Sirrus isnt deid, and Snape insnt evil just going along with what Albus wanted of him

the locket

By Jim at 2005/12/31 20:38

the locket found at the manner is a horcurx and harry will kill voldamort and Harry and Ginny will get married and he will become an Aroura and hunt down the Death Eaters

Dumbledore was Pleading For Forgiveness

By selphie (Email) at 2006/01/11 15:01

I think that Albus was actually trying to ask Snape for forgiveness before Snape killed him. I think that from the green potion guarding the fake Horcrux Albus was forced to relive a memory from the past. A memory of Snape being taken by Voldy when he was very young because in truth Snape is Gryffindor's heir and Voldemort's final Horcrux.

However, Snape reading Albus' guilt could not forgive the Headmaster for his hard life and killed him in his anger and pain. Snape is the person who destroyed the Gryffindor hourglass because it was a painful reminder of his heritage and why Voldemort had taken him and hurt him so much.

Sidetrack

By Gina (Email) at 2006/01/13 23:14

Ok. Relevant or not. Lilly, and Petunia both names are flowers. What about Narcissa? Are they all sisters, making Petunia a witch too, or a squib? What did Petunia's howler say? Was it from Dumbldore?

snape

By tori (Email) at 2006/01/14 22:50

i feel very sorry for snape, hes very misunderstood... i beleive hes just a poor innocent guy who just has a lot of anger. He obviously loved lily and couldnt handle the fact that he ended up playing a part in her being killed. He hates harry because lily died to save him. This explains why he tortured harry in HBP. Everything else snape has ever done was just because he had to do it, like killing dumbledore, he had no choice. Hes not evil, he just needs a counselor, too many pent up feelings, poor guy.

dumbeldore

By randomness (Email) at 2006/01/16 18:25

dumbeldore can not have made a horcrux or he would not have needed the fat poyion guys memory(forgot name). Also, I think we should consider how people are always correcting harry when he says Snape("proffesor snape"), what he will find when he goes to godric's hollow (that's definatly important), un-explained emotions during all of harry's training sessions with snape (by snape), and when harry stars to name death eathers in the 4th book. also, dumbuldore gets a misterious, trumphant look during harrys explaination (4th book). If you look into it, you will notice fine detials that are quite unexplained. What could they mean? Finally, notice Snapes reactions when Harry tries to kill him "don't call me a coward!". Hmmmmm......??????????

Predictions

By selphie (Email) at 2006/01/19 15:37

Dumbledore looked triumphant when he learned that Harry's blood was used as "blood of the enemy" in the spell Voldemort used to be ressurect himself because if Harry was Voldemort's horcrux his blood could not be considered blood of the enemy and the spell would have failed.

Harry is Snape's horcrux. The scar he bears is not a lightning bolt but rather a tear representing the first division of the soul. All first Horcruxes have that mark like the Marvolo ring.

Harry will use both the mirror Sirius gave him and his resemblance to his father to trick young Sirius into thinking he's James when Harry goes into the past to change a certain event.

Harry will change it so he will never be born. No longer "the boy who lived" but rather "the boy who doesn't exist" he will go into the gateway to Heaven that Sirus disappeared into in book 5.

verification

By gemma (Email) at 2006/01/26 18:43

ok, so if harry's scar really is another horcrux then that would mean the prophecy is wrong. It says voldemort will mark the boy his equal, this much is ok but dumbldore told Harry that voldemort transferred some of his powers the night he gave him his scar. Nothing was said about transferring his soul. Harry cant be the horcrux cos the prophecy states that neither can live while the other survives. This means that one can live, so this means that harry's scar isnt a horcrux cos it would mean killing himself to defeat voldemort.

Also dumbledore has to be dead cos the portraits in his office are strictly those of dead headmasters/mistresses so if dumbledore as is a portrait then he is dead. But harry will still be able to communicate with him and get help on defeating dumbledore.

One more thing could someone please help me. The thing is, i read on some site that the last word of book 7 is scar so I researched it and I found loads of sites that say the last line is "Harry, where's your scar?". If this is true then Harry obviously survives cos nobody in there right mind would ask a dead person a question like that.

So if anybody out there can let me know about that last point please tell cos the suspense is killing me.

Prediction

By Mad Eye (Email) at 2006/01/30 11:00

I think that Harry himself, is a horcrux. In the prediction made by Professor Trelawny, she said that neither could live while the other survives. If He-who-must not-be-named was to take the body of Harry after being defeated, he would annihilate Harry completely thus fulfilling the prophecy.

I also believe that Dumble himself might have been a horcrux. Did it spark any of your minds when you read that He-who-must-not-be-named visited Dumbledore shortly after he had received so much power? Even Dumbledore says it himself. Dumbledore understood this and knew that he must be destroyed. YOu may recall previously in the HBP that Hagrid overheard Snape and Dumbledore having a "quarrel" with each other. This was because Dumbledore was telling Snape that he must destroy him......and you all know that he did just that in the end.

When Harry and Dumbledor arrived in the tower, Harry was jinxed so that he couldn't move. Dumbledore did this so that Harry wouldn't do anything foolish, just as he had proved he was capable of doing when he had tried to save Sirius in OotP. SO when Snape came to the West Tower, Harry wasn't able to do anything thus allowing Snape to finish Dumbledore.

----Sorry this is a long comment, but i believe i might be right in at least one asspect of the plot that is unfolding. tell me what you think! -------

Correction

By Mad Eye (Email) at 2006/01/30 11:06

I had to make a correction after reading my last comment.

Previously stated was He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named visited Dumbledore in his office after he had started his dirty work. I wanted to clarify that during that visit, i believe Dumbledore was made a Horcrux. This then makes the rest of my prediction clear.......or so i hope. I think that Dumbledore knew that he was a horcrux and thus he knew he had to be destroyed. THis is all eviedent as you finish the book. Another thing that i must mention is that no one was allowed to touch the body of Dumbledore after he had fallen from the Tower....interesting? Well you might also remember that His body wasn't shown during the Barial......interesting?

------Let me know what you think-----

P.N. Dumbledore an animangus?

RAB

By Philip at 2006/02/18 12:52

RAB = Rookwood, Avery and Black...Harry thought he saw a ghost of a phoenix rose out from the burial site...

"ripping the soul"

By maeve neary*(amsterdam) (Email) at 2006/03/09 12:45

i keep hearing people saying that someone killed someone else and that the killer then might have ripped his soul becouse of the killing, like that dumbledore killed grindelwald and that dumbledore ripped his soul.
we know that making a horcrux and ripping your soul is very very very complicated magic, so i dont think just killing someone would do the trick, eh? also if you rip your soul just by killing someone, voldys soul must have been rippen hundreds of times, all the death eaters to and everyone in the order otphoenix loads of people in the ministry, so really people don't just rip their soul that easy. xxxmaeve

haarys scar IS a horcrux?

By maeve neary*(amsterdam) (Email) at 2006/03/09 12:51

i just read that people say the last sentence of book 6 is Harry where is your scar?!!!! maybe he then defeats voildy, and his scar si a horcrux and then he had te destroy his scar or harry killes voldy and then the last bit of his soul dies to so the last piece--> the scar dissapears!! let me know what you think, it might be a bit farfetches but hey, isnt harry potter?\

every confused article

By Aabhar Potter (Email) at 2006/03/11 07:08

the last horcrux is harrys scar and narsisca is lily and petunias sister and snape killed dumbledore as he was a horcrux and he torments harry as he loved lily and also that harry will survive but neville i am afraid has to die and the last horcrux is snapes

dumbledore not dead

By anonomis at 2006/04/07 15:49

dumbledore cant be dead. if he is than why were his eyes closed. all harry needs to do is open dumbledores eyes and see if the color is gone from them.

dumbledore is dead

By Miss Delacour (Email) at 2006/11/18 19:02

dumbledore is dead, jk rowling said so herself, in countless interviews, but I guess you guys wrote that stuff before the interviews so i dont blame you guys, but im just saying, dumbledore is dead. Also dumbledores soul cant have ripped because it says he defeated that wizard, that doesn't necessarily mean that he killed him. Also, go to muggle net .com and look up 101 ways to annoy voldemort, i laughed my head off, it has nothing to do with what you guys have been saying, but go to the site anyway. Also, jk said that the two way mirror comes back in the 7th book, will harry use it to contact sirius? or what will it be used for? and snape cant have loved lily because he hates mudbloods, and lily was muggle born. Also, lily petunia and narcissa's names being flowers does not mean that they were sisters, it was just a coincidence. And jk also said that something will be revealed about petunia, but it is not that she is a squib or a witch. I really want to discuss stuff with someone about the books, so if anyone wants to discuss stuff, send me an e-mail. I have lots of opinions, and facts, so dont be afraid to contact me. holla, Miss Delacour

My theories

By JWN at 2007/02/05 08:48

I'm sorry, but Dumbledore is dead. Sirius will return, two things lead me to this, 1: Luna told him about the voices behind the veil. 2: He is Harry's godfather, he is his guardian and will never leave him. Sirius will return, in his human form or as Padfoot. Snape is good, I think he might even die to protect Harry! Voldemort will die as will Harry.

Sirius' "return"

By Graeme (Email) at 2007/02/08 05:31

Sirius does not have to return in bodily form. Harry has two special mirrors magically attuned to Harry and Sirius. All Harry has to do is throw the mirror into the veil. That way Sirius' spirit can communicate with him plus give him all the pointers he needs to find horcruxes and defeat Mr.V.

Dumbledore's Sacrifice~

By VLM at 2007/02/15 09:55

I think that Dumbledore actually wanted Snape to kill him for a certain reason... Maybe he knew that if he sacrificed himself so that Sirius might live again and help Harry in his fight against Voldemort. Dumbledore said so himself that Sirius was torn cruelly away from him. It could be possible that by sacrificing himself Sirius may reappear from the Veil. Some may say this is idiotic because Dumbledore is more powerful than Sirius concerning magic. I'll have to find more info to support my theory. hehehe

the second war

By Lucia at 2007/02/21 18:49

I think that if Voldemort gets defeated at last, Bellatrix Lestrange will follow in Voldemort's footsteps and collect follows and start a new war.

DUMBLEDORE'S SACRIFICE

By CHRIS at 2007/05/03 21:45

DUMBLEDORE SACRIFICE HIMSELF MAYBE SO SIRIUS COULD LIVE AGAIN. DUMBLEDORE SAID IT HIM SELF THAT LOVE IS THE GREATEST MAGIC OF ALL.

my theories

By ahmad (Email) at 2007/05/20 07:39

i think that lv will die because all the order will help harry but what if harry is a horcruxe himself then he will have to die in order to kill lv .maybe all harrys protecters spirits will help harry finally defeat lord voldemort

Approaches?

By shema at 2007/06/27 18:46

The one with the power to vanquish the dark lord approaches (prophecy)could mean snape approaching Trelawny and DD at the bar. Also the barman at the Hog's Head is Aberforth (DD's brother) because Harry thinks he is familiar and he smells like goats as Aberforth was charged for charming goats.

Theories

By crookshanks at 2007/07/11 09:17

Right...
1. It is confirmed dumbledore is dead however his painting still hangs in the office.
2. Godric Hallows was the hiding place where harry and his parents hid from big V therefore could it b possible there is a horcrux there?
3. The invisibility cloak has a bigger part to play...someone else was in the house when harys parents were killed under the cloak...possibly snape.
4.RAB anyone ever thought of the timeturners involvement here? that maybe RAB are part of the order or once were...or even more facinating was a houseelf.
5. Aberforth hogshead but the necklace found by weasleys while clearing out blacks house in OotP was a horcrux and was sold by mungduns to Aberforth. Major appearance i suspect???

There we go; many a theory! :)

Add a comment:

Subject:
Name:
Email:
Url:
Title:	Don't enter anything here if you're a human.
CAPTCHA:	Don't enter anything here if you're a human.
Comment: