sab39

... indistinguishable from magic
effing the ineffable since 1977
Predictions

Predictions

7/16/2005
For those keeping score, of my nine predictions (eight days plus a bonus one on the last day) two of them were spot-on correct, one confirmed incorrect, two seem highly unlikely now, and four are still unknown (one of them was a prediction for book 7 anyway so was always going to still be unknown at this point).

Hopefully the score isn't enough of a spoiler that I should make you click through for it, but the rest of this entry contains spoilers. Don't click through if you haven't read the book yet.

Here were the predictions:

7-day (rat): It will turn out that Crabbe and Goyle senior were the ones who originally bullied Wormtail into acting as a spy for Voldemort.
Status: Still unknown.

6-day (blood): Something in Harry's blood (which Voldemort used at the end of Goblet) will prove Voldemort's downfall.
Status: Still unknown.

5-day (ships): Ron/Hermione, Harry/Ginny.
Status: Correct!

4-day (mirror): The broken shards of two-way mirror that Sirius gave to Harry will communicate with each other. Harry and his friends will use these to great effect.
Status: Unlikely. No mention of the mirror at all.

3-day (grade): By some injustice, Harry will turn out to have failed his Defense Against the Dark Arts O.W.L.
Status: Incorrect.

2-day (army): The D.A. will get some kind of pseudo-official recognition, perhaps as a kind of "junior arm" to the Order of the Phoenix.
Status: Unlikely. By next year everyone except Ginny will be old enough to join the Order outright.

1-day (death): Dumbledore will die.
Status: Correct! (but of all the things to be right about...)

0-day (more death): Harry will die at the end of Book 7.
Status: Still unknown, of course.

Bonus prediction: Caradoc Dearborn's going to show up and turn out to be either a Death Eater spy or a Death Eater hostage.
Status: Still unknown.
Harry/Ginny
By Anon at 2005/07/18 04:42

Dumbledore was leaked to the press a while ago. Ron+Hermione was "obvious"

I don't see how you figured Harry+Ginny though.

Not hard
By Stuart Ballard at 2005/07/18 13:30

I hadn't heard Dumbledore being leaked to the press, but admittedly I can't take full credit for it. I read an article comparing HP to other "hero" stories and pointing out that it's a necessary point in every such story that the hero must eventually survive without protection.

Ron/Hermione wasn't quite as obvious as everyone seems to think (including me until about the 7th reread of the books ;) ). If you actually look closely enough, there have been hints that Hermione might have had feelings for Harry - among other things, she kissed him "good luck" in _Goblet_ (I think) but didn't kiss Ron "good luck" until _Phoenix_. Even early in _Prince_ I was still in doubt - her reaction to Harry calling her "the best witch in the year" had me thinking I was wrong for a while.

Harry/Ginny has been one of *many* (contradictory) romances predicted by fans for a long, long time. They go from the obvious (Ron/Hermione, Harry/Ginny, Harry/Hermione) to the insane (Harry/Draco and Ron/Giant Squid (which had me in absolute hysterics when it actually happened in this book, albeit metaphorically)).

I felt that JKR had been leading up to Harry/Ginny for ages. There was her initial crush on him, which didn't necessarily mean anything but made it nicely poetic when they did get together. There was Ron's subtle hint "just choose someone... better... next time" with a nod to Harry at the end of _Phoenix_, which made clear that not *all* the Weasleys had given up on the idea. And there was the fact that since _Phoenix_ Harry had begun to notice her real personality, and that she was coming into her own as a witch (eg at the final Ministry battle, but before that too). I also thought her personality as shown in _Phoenix_ was really fun and likeable, and I figured that since we're seeing her "through Harry's eyes", as it were, he'd notice the same thing.

Even though they're not together as of the end of the book, I'm not giving up on their getting back together before Harry's death at the end of Book 7 (yes, I'm sticking to that one). Harry may be pretty resolute, but I don't see Ginny giving up so easily. Too much Fred and George in her!

ron/hermione
By hpfan at 2005/07/23 16:34

Ron/Hermione may have acted as tho they liked each other.... but they were nevr OFFICIALLY together

Dating
By Mike at 2005/07/27 16:19

1. Hermione/Ron was obvious. The "clues" that Hermione liked Harry weren't clues at all. Like many girls her age, Hermione was very comfortable showing affection and caring for the boy she didnt have a crush on (Harry) and had a harder time being affectionate with the boy she did want to date. The tension and jealousy between Ron and Hermione has been there since book 4.

As far as Ginny/Harry. I also thought this would occur, simply because the lead in each story has to have a love interest. The seeds of ginny's feelings toward Harry had always been there, plus Harry has basically been part of the Weasley family, so if he and Ginny ever got hitched, it would be official.

Good call on the Dumbledore death. My prediction (a long time ago) was that Hagrid would die in book 5, Dumbledore in book 6, and Ron in book 7. I hope I am wrong about Ron, but I fear he is going to die.

Also, it is obvious for a number of reasons that Snape is good, and was merely doing what he had to do to keep the goal of taking down Voldemort alive.

Harry as a horcrux
By Csin at 2005/07/29 10:15

I have a few reasons to believe why Harry would be the last horcrux. DD already told Harry that’s he is connected to LV through the scar, that when LV died a part of him went into Harry hint hint. DD also stated that LV wanted to save his last horcrux for a very special kill. We also now that LV wanted his last Horcrux to have something relating to Gryffindor and LV must have known that James Potter was from the House Gryffindor therefore Harry must be of Gryffindor as well. Also we know that LV fears Harry as the one who will undo him. So my theory is LV saw Harry as the perfect Horcrux a. Harry was bond to be in house Gryffindor like his father b. Harry has importance to LV because of the prophecy c. LV just made a significant kill d. who would suspect Harry as a horcrux. For all reasoning LV sees that if Harry lives as a horcrux then he lives as well, but if Harry is killed then what harm comes to LV, other them him losing a horcrux, a small price to pay when you have 6 other. I say that before LV attempted to kill Harry for the first time, he completed his last horcrux to be Harry as a safe guard just in case something goes wrong because if Harry lives so does LV but if Harry dies nothing happens to LV just the kind of evil thing LV would think of. We also know that LV doesn't want any of the DE to kill Harry because of what Snape shouted in the recent battle. This possible because LV wants to kill Harry himself because he is a horcrux and some how he wants to save the last bit of his soul to make another horcrux???. I also believe in order for Harry to defeat LV he himself must die therefore ending the story. As you can see from the way the books develops, Harry really does not have much to live for other then defeating LV. He doesn't really doesn't have any family, he just lost DD and the road he now must take is leading him away from the only other person he loves (Ginny) . Of course I can be totally wrong and the Horcrux and be the hat lol.

Harry Not As A Horcrux
By Anonny at 2005/08/06 00:59

Your point is very well backed up. But say Harry finds all the horcruxes and he is the last one. If Voldemort kills him, wont he then e putting himself in obvious danger because he can now be killed? Or is he running on Harry being the only one who can ever kill him?

HArry as not a horcrux
By Anna-Marie at 2005/08/09 14:28

Why wouldwhy would voldy want a part of him dead and when did he have time to put the spell on harry

Last Chapter
By anon at 2005/08/14 15:15

Did anyone else see the direct similarities in the spider man movies and the funeral scene in HBP.

Finally after Mary-jane and Peter get together he breaks up with her because it is too dangerous for his enemies to get to him through her, and he must go off on his own to fight evil.

Also both happen at the grave of their mentor (harry-dd) (peter-uncle ben.)

Harry as a horcrux
By Chris at 2005/08/17 09:49

Maybe harry was a horcrux but at the end of the goblet of fire, the use of harry's blood to bring voldemort back to power was infact voldemort taking back the piece of his soul left in Harry?

harry/ginny
By insane guy (Email) at 2005/08/18 14:54

i reckon the whole romantic thing is a loead of dung

caradoc dearborn
By Shannon at 2005/08/20 03:03

Who is Caradoc Dearborn? Don't remember that name at all.

Caradoc
By Stuart Ballard at 2005/08/21 15:33

In Moody's old picture of the original Order, in the chapter "The Woes of Mrs Weasley" in _Phoenix_, nearly all the people we've already met or are known dead. The only exceptions are Aberforth Dumbledore (who we've met but not by name) and Caradoc Dearborn, who they "never found"...

Caradoc
By Yell at 2005/12/20 14:37

Wasn't it Caradoc, Aberforth and Benjy Fenwick? As far as I can gather they only 'ever found bits of him' which, while it is likely he's dead, may be a hint because they only ever found a bit of Pettigrew.

Harry as a horcrux!
By Lauz (Email) at 2006/01/06 06:47

Harry should be a horcrux!!When Voldemort realised he shouldnt use a person as a horcrux,he set out to kill Harry, wanting to kill harry first so none of the other horcruxes could be destroyed. (He knew Dumbledore wouldn't live long enough to destroy them all)
Dumbledore said something along the lines of 'it is unwise to put part of yourself in something that can think and move by itself' DIRECTLY followed by 'i am almost certain that lord voldemort was one horcrux short of his seven on the night he entered your house'!!!
This would also explain Harry acquiring some of LV's powers and an insight into his thoughts and feelings. If Harry destroyed himself, LV would be human and could therefore be killed.

Hermione/Ron
By Aldara at 2006/01/11 21:46

If she's a smart girl, and I think she is, she'll dump him before book seven is over. They're just too different. They're constantly arguing. They don't appreciate each other's interests (learning/books vs. quidditch). Even if they get together, I don't think their relationship could last.

Hermione/Ron
By Lauz (Email) at 2006/01/13 05:44

Yeah but they may only be arguing because they get frustrated that they like each other but neither of them will admit it. I think when and if they finally get together they will be really happy- you mention different interests but Ron would never tell Hermione not to read or study and Hermione is always going to watch Quidditch matches, especially if Harry or Ron are playing.
As they say-opposites attract, i don't agree that 'if she's a smart girl she will dump him before book seven is over' because they do love each other, even if it turns out just to be as friends. And being smart is to make yourself happy, she wouldnt be harming anyone. Being different to each other does not make either of them a bad person.
I think it could last, unless of course one of them dies! :(
Sorry!just my point of view.x

Herry and Hermione
By Alexz at 2006/01/15 16:27

I think Harry and Hermione well get together. I hope, because there has been things said about Lily that can be seen in Hermiione. Also in 5 though she seem to like Ron I think she loves Harry.

Hermionie/ron
By lizzie (Email) at 2006/01/28 15:52

i think hermionie and ron should go out. they ARE meant for each other, how can you possibly say that hermionie should dump him? she isnt even going out with him! they only argue because they like each other!

Harry and Hermione= EVIL RON!!
By Jenny at 2006/01/29 15:06

I think Harry and Hermione should get together because we have already seen how spiteful ron and harry can be to each other when annoyed!
If Harry got with Hermione Ron could turn evil and become a death eater,he is so angry he pretends to make up with Harry to set up a trap and lead him to Voldermort.But in the nick of time-Rons realises his mistake and saves Harry then Harry kills Voldermort.
Hermione becomes pregnant with Harry's baby and Ron realises he is madly in love with Luna.
Also Neville gets famous and everyone fancies him!!
Unlikely,but it would be grand!!

I don't want to be mean, but...
By Lonely in Cambridge :-( (Email) at 2006/01/30 16:26

Jenny, I'm sure you've put a lot of work into that theory, but it's just not very logical.
As you said, it is "unlikely", and I think you should just think of it as sort of like a good dream- stupid anywhere else but the head.

last horcrux
By SS (Email) at 2006/02/05 08:17

I know that harry's mother's dead body is the last horcrux
because I heard it from jo when she was sleeping. (she always talks in her dreams)
Sorry jo but I must tell that everyone!!!!!

no!
By jkrowling at 2006/02/05 08:19

You mustn't say that you filthy woman because of you I have to change the end!!!!!!!!!!

The new ending.
By Jenny the half blood Prince. at 2006/02/05 10:38

Can i be in the end?

Ron is in love with Hermione
By sarah (Email) at 2006/02/10 23:13

I definitely think that ron/hermione gonna get together. i mean look at book 4. ron was super jealous. then comes book 6. hermione was super jealous. oh gosh i hope they start going out!

Ron and Hemione= Yes please,but not til the epilogue!!
By Lauz at 2006/02/12 05:35

If Ron and Hermione get together at the start or the middle of the book-one of them is certainly going to be killed off...therefore the romance should start as close to the end as possible. Even in the last chapter they stand no chance. We have all been told (truthfully or not) that the last word is 'scar'. So the last sentence of the book should read 'Oh, and then Ron and Hermione got together and had babies but none of them had a scar.'That way they are safe= no more HP books.

Although, one of them could still die if they don't get together then the other one will be tormented with 'oh why didnt we just get together' for the rest of their lives.

The last book is gonna be so sad i may have to tear the pages out and write an alternate ending.

You know it makes sense!!

Epilogue romance
By LauzY at 2006/02/12 08:15

Lauz you are so right that they need to get together at the VERY end (how about: "Ron and Hermione's wedding day was very happy, but they could never forget their dearly departed best friend- the one with the scar."! You like?)

But the problem is that means we miss out on all the soppy romantic bits, and the bit where they realise they're so totally in love with each other, just as the Avada Kedavra curse hits one or both of them.

You have to admit that letting them fall in love a little earlier is great for dramatic purposes, or perhaps not so great for suicidally obsessive fans...

Horcrux.
By Amanda. at 2006/02/21 10:34

I believe that Harry is a horcrux, because his scar is the same as the mark left on the ring, which was also a horcrux. The ring got it's mark from being made into a horcrux.
It annoys me that some people say that Harry's scar is the horcrux- Harry was given this scar by the spell cast by Lord Voldermort (wether that was avada kedavra or the horcrux spell) and Harry did not have his scar prior to this occasion. Therefore it did not exist to case some part of LV's soul in.

yay!
By lauzy wauzy at 2006/02/21 11:32

Amanda thank you so much!
What you said was exactly the same as what me and lauz (no, we're not the same person) always say! It IS ridiculous to call the scar a horcrux!

Thank you

ginny and harry being married
By Ronshalee (Email) at 2006/02/22 13:01

i think that harry will marry ginny and have many little harry's and ginny's

hermione and hermione
By jilly at 2006/02/22 14:32

In the 6th book harry mentioned that he will not come back to hogwarts.I remember reading an article quoting that J.K. rowling said that Harry will be in hogwarts in all the books. I believe that something very bad will happen to ginny and Ron. Harry will only come back just to protect hermione from voldermort being that she is muggle born and she is in more danger than harry. after harry defeats voldermort hermione and harry will become more than just best friends or even have like a "Brother/Sister" relationship . I believe they will get together.

Agree for most!
By Lauz at 2006/02/23 03:39

Jilly, i agree on all of your comments-except how could Hermione be in more danger than Harry?She is just a muggle-born whereas harry took all of LV's power away from him and took those valuable killing years from him!!

thank you for responding lauz
By jilly at 2006/02/23 22:27

I read an editorial on mugglenet called the boy who loved, or why love conquers all, Even though it talks about ron being his closest friend rather than hermione, i think that harry loves her more than anyone. i am not really sure but i believe that Voldermort dislikes muggle-borns very much. since hermione is a muggle-born and harry loves her annnnd she may be the only one remaining that harry cares about she is in so much danger. after reading the editorial i believe that voldermort will use hermione to get to harry being that he is the hero and he obvious will rescue her. I believe that love overcomes power.

this is fun!
By lauzy at 2006/02/25 11:07

Jilly- you forget one crucial point. Voldemort doesn't care for love. He thinks it's useless. You may believe that love overcomes power, but Voldemort certainly doesn't. I'm going to paraphrase here because i can't be bothered to get my book but i'm sure in one of the memories in HBP voldemort says something like "In all my studies I have never found any evidence to suggest the love is stronger than any magic".

And even if Voldemort does suddenly get a bang to the head and realise the power of love, Harry is still the main target. Hermione and Harry's other friends would only be in danger BECAUSE of their affiliation to Harry, so I don't really feel justified in agreeing that Harry would be in less danger (although if he's going to die it will have to be at the end of the book so if he comes across Voldemort before the end then everyone else is in more danger than him).

Anyway, Harry loves Ginny, possibly more than he loves Ron or Hermione. And even though they're not together any more, the feeling is still there and Voldemort, smart as he is, wouldn't miss that.

I know
By jilly at 2006/02/25 16:37

why those harry have to love ginny. no offense but I don't like ginny she got in the way. why cant harry love hermione more. she cares and worries about him so much more. this makes me want to cry

ooops
By jilly at 2006/02/25 16:38

Did i say those I meant does

Ok
By Jenny. at 2006/02/27 09:55

Ok, now you make a good point. As you don't like Ginny, let's just make Harry forget her.

P.s-Voldermort wants to destroy Harry, the reason people Harry loves die is because they go with Harry when he meets Voldermort, therefore getting in the way. LV doesn't set out to kill them.

p.p.s-Hermione is not the only muggle born in the world- there are others! I think if she gets killed it will be by a death eater not LV!

flibble
By plibble at 2006/03/01 15:21

Jilly, Harry and Hermione are just friends. I would bet my right arm on it.

And Jenny is totally right- people close to Harry die for two reasons: one, that they're prepared to risk their lives for him; two, for highly-important plot purposes!

and a little addition...
By plibble at 2006/03/01 15:26

NOT because they happen to be muggleborn. As Tom Riddle says in COS- "killing mudbloods doesn't matter to me any more. For some time now, my target has been...you." (total paraphrasing there!)
So voldemort isn't going to see harry and hermione and think "oh, no, which to choose? well, harry is my mortal enemy whose destiny is either to kill or be killed by me, but then again, hermione is a muggleborn! KILL HER"
It doesn't quite work, does it?

Snape.
By Rose. at 2006/03/02 04:54

I do not think that Snape is evil, Dumbledore seriously convinced Snape to kill him, there are many hints throughout HBP.
Why would Dumbledore trust Snape without good reason and why would he ut a spell on Harry so he could not do anything? Harry overhears Dumbledore convincing Snape to go through with something. Dumbledore know's what is going on around him and believes his time is up and Harry is ready for his fate.

Of at a tangent!
By Jenny at 2006/03/02 12:36

If your name is 'Stuart Ballard' and you are 'S.A.B' not 'SAB' then maybe it was a typing error in HBP(S instead of R)and maybe YOU got rid of the horcrux!!

LIES!
By R.A.B at 2006/03/07 14:12

Jenny, you know nothing.

It is I who am R.A.B- my initials stand for really annoying b*****d!

But shhh!
don't tell anyone!

JK Rowling's paying me to keep it quiet!

Essay On Snape's Evilness
By Laurarararaaaaa! at 2006/03/07 14:41

Before HBP was released, I was convinced that Snape was evil. The way I saw it, it would be the ultimate betrayal. I did not, of course, predict that he would be the one to kill Dumbledore, but I knew that if Snape raised his wand in support of Voldemort, Dumbledore would be heartbroken- of everyone, he seemed to trust Severus Snape most.

I'm not trying to make people like Snape- for all his intriguing complexities as a character, for all his innate goodness (if my theory is true), he will never be a nice person. I will never forgive him for his treatment of Harry and those closest to him. But we need to realise that a horrible person isn't necessarily an evil one.

I'm not sure why he trusted him. The fact that he apologised for telling Voldemort what he heard of the prophecy can't be enough, surely? No, I think that when Dumbledore told Harry this, he was lying. Think about it- Dumbledore knows how much Harry hates Snape. Perhaps he didn't think Harry could handle the truth about why Snape was so vital.

Cast your mind back to Occlumency in OOP- one of the memories Harry sees when he enters Snape's memory is one of a dark-haired baby on the floor whilst a hook-nosed man and a scared-looking woman argue- is it really so far-fetched to think, maybe the child is Harry? Maybe the man is Snape? Maybe the woman is Lily Potter? And maybe, just maybe, Snape was at Godric's Hollow shortly before Voldemort killed the Potters? Maybe he warned them that Voldemort knew where they were (As to how Snape knew where they were, perhaps Wormtail told him whilst they were both on Death Eater duty)? Maybe Snape even told Lily how to give Harry her protection?

But that was all a side point. All we know is that Dumbledore trusted Snape, for whatever reason, and that Snape killed Dumbledore. I disagree with Rose and other people who say that Dumbledore told Snape to kill him. There is no reason why Dumbledore would want to die, without even telling Harry how to find and destroy horcruxes! As to the conversation Hagrid overheard, I know it's a bit radical but how about entertaining the fact that Hagrid was actually right? It's the perfect bluff: Hagrid overhears Dumbledore telling Snape he has agreed to do something (Take a job that will only last a year? Have to teach Harry? Act as a spy amongst people he detests? Who knows?) and HAS to continue doing it. Harry, of course, jumps to the conclusion that Snape is evil and wants to back out of being in the Order and, because we love Harry, we agree with him. But we know that Harry isn't always right. I think the Snape/Dumbledore conversation was innocent.

So, then we have a problem. We have Snape, who I think is a good guy, but he kills another good guy, with seemingly no reason. But he DIDN'T have no reason, did he? No. No he didn't.

You see, as the wonderful Chapter 2 of HBP tells us, Snape made the Unbreakable Vow, and he promised to help Draco as much as he could and do his job for him if he couldn't do it. All of a sudden, Snape finds himself with Draco unable to do that job, and Snape has a dilemma: does he:

a) refuse to kill Dumbledore, thus abandoning his position as double agent, dying by whichever nasty means the breaking of the Unbreakable Vow forces upon a person, and leaving Hogwarts infested with a bunch of Death Eaters who would not only kill Dumbledore anyway, but also as many staff, students and Order members as they can handle.

OR

b) kill Dumbledore, finding himself no longer bound to the Unbreakable Vow, maintaining his position (even if the Order won't take him back, he can still do some pretty nasty inside-damage of his own accord if he wants to) and escaping Hogwarts with all of the other Death Eaters present on his tail- leaving all the inhabitants of Hogwarts (excluding himself, Dumbledore, and Draco, of course) grieving and shocked, but alive, and, for now, safe.

Put that way, which would you choose?

Snape found himself in an impossible situation, and he did what he thought was right. You notice that he only got angry with Harry when he called him a coward? Perhaps that's because there will always be the niggling doubt in Snape's mind that what he did was cowardly, that he only did it for self-preservation. Yet it is undeniable that what Snape did actually saved the people of Hogwarts. It's just that they can't see it, because in doing what he did, Snape took away someone who meant as much to them as he did to Snape.

I'm sorry this comment was so long! If you've survived to the end, congratulations!

(On a lighter note) Proffessor Trelawney= Harry's father.
By Harold at 2006/03/12 14:25

Proffessor Trelawney is not a drunk hidng sherry bottles, she is hiding polyjuice potion.
Harry's dad never died, he is Proffessor Trelawney, the real Proffessor Trelawney is locked in a box in Neville's Grandma's attic.

Harold, you might be on to something there! But Professor has only one 'f'.
By My name is not Earl. at 2006/03/13 11:35

I totally agree! Polyjuice Potion has not yet used up all of its importance in the HP series.

I think ex-Professor Snape is Harry's mother. She killed Dumbledore because Dumbledore was a transsexual who kept wearing Lily Potter's pretty clothes (she didn't need them as Snape).

The real Professors Trelawney and Snape are in a box in Neville's Grandma's attic, knitting clothes for house-elves and pretending to be various inanimate objects.

It's a sad world.

Don't be so silly!
By Jennifer at 2006/03/15 14:07

I feel I must reassert the sanity of this thread.

Let's all calm down and look at the accounts!

GO ON THIS JOURNAL!!
By Laura and Laura at 2006/03/17 11:38

http://journals.aol.co.uk/lauzypoo/HP_Theories

Wow!
By Jim at 2006/03/17 11:58

Laura and Laura, that journal is so good!
by the time it's got lots of theories on it will be brilliant!

It was there all the time
By Abby at 2006/03/19 18:06

It's really not fair, if J.K. was gonna wanted Harry and Ginny to get together she should have mentioned Ginny more in books 1-5, I mean it's just that Harry and Hermione were always there showing affection, but nooo she had to ruin the whole story!!!!! I want to cry!!!!!!

This is *not at all* sarcastic
By Jenny at 2006/03/24 11:48

Because, of course, Ginny was not at all mentioned in the first 5 books. Ron has a sister? Yer wha?

And, of course, Harry and Ginny make a harrible couple. Love? Pah, who needs that?

And finally, the person Harry gets with is so-incredibly-crucial to the plot that him and Ginny means a TOTALLY different ending to any other relationship.

Yeah.

Nobody's A Horcrux (a totally serious thought)
By Puff the Magic Hungarian Horntail at 2006/03/25 08:05

What if, that fateful night when Voldie fullfilled the prophecy, he was hoping to kill Harry and use that murder as the making of his last Horcrux... and failed.

And that brings another thought to mind- did Voldie split his soul into 7 equal pieces? So that he now has 2/7ths left? Or does he divide his soul into halves each time? Like, here, a half to my first Horcrux, a quarter to my second, an eighth to my third...

harry/hermione or harry/ginny
By miss mione (Email) at 2006/03/27 22:17

even though i think harry and hermione are going to be, here's what going to say: harry still loves ginny, but harry had to push away because he was scared she was going to get killed. but what if she gets killed anyway? WHO CARES?!? i mean come on!there was some clues that hermione COULD OF(underline could of) liked harry. I, unlike some of you,(or all of you)have all of the books. and i had some clues about H/Hr

H/hr (harry/hermione)
By the hungarian horntail (Email) at 2006/03/27 22:23

i think you are TOTALLY right miss mione! i mean i bet she only liked him because he was famous! get the word FAMOUS, people???

I agee with you
By jillybird at 2006/04/15 17:46

I Know I am Kind of Late but I agree you (The hungarian horntail, miss mione)about ginny just liking harry because he's famous. angd to come to think of it ginny doesn't really know harry the way hermine knows him. besides hermine and harry just look cute together. (by the way todays emma watson's b-day) any way! Even if ron and hermione get together i don't think their relationship will last that long they fight to much.

Hate to spoil the party...
By Jenny at 2006/07/16 11:27

Miss Mione, you just wish you were Hermione and you had Harry!
J K Rowling herself has said Ron and Hermione secretly want to get together, not Harry and Hermione (check www.mugglenet.com for confirmation). Harry and Hermione are friends- the clues show they care for each other in a FRIENDLY way.

And of course we've read all the books, why else would we make predictions?

You make me sad.

Harry/Ginny
By Laura at 2006/07/24 07:27

Harry and Ginny are VERY similar to James and Lily- surely this is no coincidence?
It is as if Lily and James have a second chance together through Harry and Ginny.

As for Ginny only liking him because he is 'famous', this is ridiculous! You wouldn't say that Ron only likes him because of this reason, and it is the same for Ginny. Maybe this was true for a year or two, but when he saves her life in COS, she sees him as far more than a 'celebrity' and their relationship moves forward.
JKR has stated that she wanted Ginny to mature before she got with Harry, for her to know Harry as a person, not 'The Boy Who Lived'.
It is said that Ginny 'gives up' on Harry, she never stops liking him.
And let's not forget- Harry begins to see Ginny in that light too, she didn't force him to love her.
I believe they will get together when LV is destroyed.

Laura's right!
By Jenny at 2006/07/24 08:37

I think that OOP shows a definite progression in their relationship, because they talk to each other like adults and often there are moments when they catch each other's eye or mutter silly comments to each other. Once they started being like that- once Ginny stopped being obsessed with him- they really do make a good couple.

And let's not forget- she made him happy. For a short while, Harry had some love in his life. And not Crazy Crying Cho based love, actual love. You can't begrudge him that, surely?

Harry/Ginny Hermoine/Draco
By Ameenah T. Muhammad (Email) at 2006/11/08 20:14

I luv this website. I love the whole Harry Potter world.

Harry/Hermoine
By Sunshine (Email) at 2006/11/08 20:16

I read on another website that Harry and Hermoine in their sixth year or seventh at hogwarts that they sleep naked in the Grffindor prefects bathtub and had a baby 9 months later.

Harry & Hermone
By Summer at 2006/11/24 16:29

I love to see Harry and Hermione together in their 6th and 7th years. They have a lot of common. They're meant to be together. They will have baby together in the future. They're both familiar to James and Lily.

Harry/Hermione
By sophie (Email) at 2006/12/10 13:36

Hermione and harry will definetly get together somehow. they are ment for each other. even if ron and hermione get toghether at the start of 7th book i think hermione will split up with him to be with harry and then ron will go with luna and neville with ginny it all fits. the hints on ron and hermione are obvious but if you look closely wen reading you will find that there are some hints of harry and hermione.

All these Harry/hermione arfe making me laugh
By Katie (Email) at 2007/03/04 17:38

All of the topics with Harry/Hermione,seriiously get real HARRY AND HERMIONE ARE NOT GONNA BE TOGETHER--->J/K ROLWING HAS SAID IT HER SELF!!!!!!
Ok Summer your making me laugh,Hermione getting pregnaut? in her 6th year..wow that clearly shows you dont read the books at all...
And sophie,your prediction is ok..But its not gonna happend...please you guys sound so stupid when you guys say Harry and hermione are gonna get together...seriously shut up you sound stupid and your making me laugh hard..Harry and Hermione are only like brother and sister..EVEN JK said it herself..

Now my prediction is this..

In The begging of the book..Harry is gonna go to the wedding and Ron and is gonna see Krum at the wedding..Obviously Krum is gonna talk to Hermione...Krum and Hermione are gonna dance and talk...Ron is gonna get jealous and absoutley mad...

Soo then Ron is gonna talk to Hermione and Hermione and ron are gonna end up arguingAnd Hermione is about to yell say something and for ron to get her to shutup..Ron is gonna kiss her...and then boom thats how there relationship is gonna last..
for awhile and its gonna help Harry fight lordvoldemort

But i think for this to truely end is gonna have to be this Harryand Voldemort,and Snape are gonna die..
Cause to me i think this whole time Snape is indeed a fact a good person.

Soo thats what i think

horcrux
By jave at 2007/05/26 16:46

anyone else think that maybe the last horcrux is peters arm?

Add a comment:
Subject:
Name:
Email:
Url:
Title: Don't enter anything here if you're a human.
CAPTCHA: Don't enter anything here if you're a human.
Comment: